Mama Mia's Menu

When you're in the mood for some delicious, home-style Italian food, you can't go wrong with Mama Mia's Menu. Located at 8533 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI, this cozy spot offers a variety of mouthwatering dishes that cater to every taste. From freshly baked pizzas topped with the finest ingredients to pasta dishes that bring the flavors of Italy straight to your table, there's something for everyone. The menu also features hearty salads, savory appetizers, and classic Italian desserts that will leave you craving more. Whether you're dining in or taking your meal to go, Mama Mia's ensures each dish is made with love and served with a smile, making it the perfect choice for a casual meal with family and friends.

Party Pans - Large Entrees: 10 garlic bread. Serves 16-20 people. Small Entrees: 6 garlic bread and serve 8-10 people. No bread with salad.

Large Lasagna party pan
One of our signature dishes. Layers of pasta, mozzarella cheese and our homemade MeatSauce. (Full size buffet pan/steam pan.)
US$159.95
Small Lasagna party pan
One of our signature dishes. Layers of pasta, mozzarella cheese and our homemade MeatSauce. (Half size buffet pan/steam pan.)
US$84.95
Large Spinach Lasagna party pan
Layers of pasta, spinach, ricotta and Asiago cheese and Marinara. (Does not contain meat) (Full size buffet pan/steam pan.)
US$159.95
Small Spinach Lasagna party pan
Layers of pasta, spinach, ricotta and Asiago cheese and Marinara. (Does not contain meat) (Half size buffet pan/steam pan.)
US$84.95
Large Ravioli party pan
Ravioli-beef, choice or combo of both. Choice of Meatsauce or Marinara
US$135.95
Small Ravioli party pan
Ravioli-beef, choice or combo of both. Choice of Meatsauce or Marinara
US$84.95
Large Fettuccini Alfredo party pan
US$159.95
Small Fettuccini Alfredo party pan
US$84.95
Large Spaghetti/Mostaccioli party pan
Choice of our signature meatsauce or marinara
US$129.95
Small Spaghetti/Mostaccioli party pan
Choice of our homemade Meatsauce or Marinara
US$74.95
Large Chicken Parmesan party pan
Includes a bed of pasta. Served with 20 baked chicken breasts
US$229.95
Small Chicken Parmesan party pan
Includes a bed of pasta. Served with 10 baked chicken breasts
US$119.95
Large Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo party pan
Served with 6 diced oven baked chicken breasts.
US$189.95
Small Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo party pan
Served with 4 diced oven-baked chicken breasts.
US$104.95
Large Italian Salad party pan
Serves 30 people. Does NOT include garlic bread. Most people choose on House Dressing, but others available on request.
US$55.95
Small Italian Salad party pan
Serves 15 people. Does NOT include garlic bread. Most people choose on House Dressing, but others available on request.
US$29.95
Garlic Bread 10-pack
US$34.99

SANDWICHES - vegetable toppings (mushroom, onion, green pepper) at no charge. Mozzarella cheese is $1.00. Add waffle fries for $1.95

Grilled Cheese - served on our Signature Garlic Bread
Our Garlic Bread, sliced in half, with oven melted Mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of Meatsauce or Marinara available on request.
US$10.50
Meatball
Served on our Signature Garlic Bread
US$12.50
Sausage Patty
We use the same sausage thats on our pizza. It's handformed and served on our Signature Garlic Bread
US$12.50
Italian Beef
Served on a toasted Gonnella hoagie bun with a side of Au Jus. Giardiniera on request.
US$12.50
Sicilian Chicken sandwich
Baked Chicken breast topped with Mozz cheese and Marinara served on a toasted Gonnella hoagie bun
US$11.50
Chicken Parmesan sandwich
A deep-fried chicken breast with Mozzarella cheese and Marinara sauce served on a toasted Gonnella hoagie bun.
US$12.50

Dinner Entrees - available all Day. Lunch portions available 11am to 3pm. Served with one Garlic Bread. (Gluten Free Mostaccioli +0.50 cent)

Lasagna - our version of this classic Italian dish
A signature dish. Layers of noodles and MeatSauce topped with oven melted Mozzarella cheese.
US$15.99
Spinach Lasagna
Layers of noodles topped with Ricotta and Spinach mix, topped with Marinara sauce and Mozzarella and Asiago cheese.
US$15.99
Baked Pasta with Mozzarella cheese
Oven baked penne and meatsauce or marinara sauce topped with Mozzarella cheese
US$14.99
Manicotti
Ricotta cheese baked in large pasta rolls with Marinara sauce, topped with oven melted Mozzarella cheese
US$14.99
Chicken Parmesan
Two marinated chicken breasts, hand breaded with Garlic Bread crumbs and Parmesan cheese. Served atop a bed of pasta with Marinara or Meatsauce and oven melted Mozzarella cheese.
US$20.95
Eggplant Parmesan
Handcut eggplant rounds breaded with our homemade Garlic Bread crumbs. Topped with Marinara and melted 100% Mozzarella cheese. Served on a bed of pasta.
US$16.50
Spaghetti with homemade Meatsauce or marinara sauce
US$13.99
Mostaccioli with Meatsauce or Marinara sauce
US$13.99
Ravioli-beef or cheese
Served with Meatsauce or Marinara
US$14.50
Fettuccine Alfredo
A delicious dish made with heavy cream, garlic and a Romano/Parmesan cheese blend. Served with Fettucini noodles.
US$16.99
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
US$21.94

Lunch Entrees - available every day from 11am to 3pm. Served with one Garlic Bread.

Lasagna - our version of this classic Italian dish
US$10.99
Spinach Lasagna
a tasty blend of pasta, spinach, Ricotta cheese and Asiago cheese.
US$10.99
Baked Pasta with Mozzarella cheese
Oven baked penne and meatsauce or marinara sauce topped with Mozzarella cheese
US$10.50
Manicotti
US$10.50
Chicken Parmesan
A deep-fried chicken breast topped with Mozzarella cheese and Marinara sauce. Served on a bed of pasta
US$14.50
Eggplant Parmesan
Deep-fried strips of eggplant, hand-breaded and deep fried.
US$11.95
Spaghetti with Meatsauce or Marinara sauce
US$10.50
Mostaccioli with Meatsauce or Marinara sauce
US$10.50
Ravioli - beef or cheese
Served with Meatsauce or Marinara sauce
US$10.50
Fettuccine Alfredo
Long fettuccine noodles served with a creamy Alfredo sauce made from scratch
US$12.99
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
A delicious dish made with heavy cream, garlic and a Romano/Parmesan cheese blend. Served with Fettucini noodles and a diced oven baked Chicken breast.
US$17.94

SALADS - our classic salad since 1954. Iceberg and Romaine lettuce, Mozzarella cheese cubes, Pepperoni slices, diced tomatoes, pepperoncini

Dinner Salad
A salad for one. Not served with Garlic Bread
US$3.99
Medium Salad
Serves 1-2 people. Includes one Garlic Bread
US$9.75
Large Salad
Serves up to 4 people. Includes 2 Garlic Bread
US$15.25
Salad Dressings
Salad dressing sufficient for the size of salad ordered will be complimentary. More salad dressing or different ones can be purchased under SIDES. Choices are: House (Homemade Italian), Ranch, French, 1000 Island, Peppery Peppercorn, Honey Dijon Mustard, Bleu Cheese
US$0.00
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, homemade garlic bread croutons and tasty Caesar dressing.
US$4.99
Caesar Salad Entree
a large portion of our side Caesar Salad + a Garlic Bread. You can add anchovies or chicken also.
US$10.95

SIDES and SAUCES

Pasta
2/3 pint size container with pasta and Marinara or Meatsauce
US$4.50
Meatball - qty 1
one meatball made in house
US$3.50
Sausage Link
a terrific tasting sausage from our purveyor from Chicago IL
US$4.25
Chicken Breast
an oven-baked chicken breast
US$4.95
Anchovies
US$2.50
French Fries - waffle cut
US$1.95
Cup Meatsauce
8 oz serving
US$3.50
Cup - Marinara
8 oz
US$1.99
Cup - Alfredo Sauce
8 oz. serving
US$3.99
Pint - Meatsauce
16 oz. serving
US$7.50
Pint - Marinara sauce
2 cups of our Marinara sauce
US$3.99
Pint Alfredo Sauce
16 oz. serving
US$7.99
Quart - Meatsauce
32 oz. serving
US$13.99
Quart - Marinara
4 cups of Marinara sauce
US$7.99
Quart Alfredo Sauce
32 oz. serving
US$15.99
Quart Soup
US$10.50
Quart Salad Dressing
US$8.50

PIZZA - made with our Famous Thin Crust. Small is 11" and Large is 14". Mini is 9" and available at lunch only.

Small cheese pizza
11" round pizza
US$12.95
Large Cheese pizza
14" round pizza
US$16.75
Mini Cheese Pizza
9" round pizza. Available at lunch only 11am to 3pm.
US$8.25
Premium toppings for Small pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, Canadian ham, anchovies, chopped garlic, pineapple, pepperoncini, extra cheese.
US$2.50
Premium toppings for Large
Sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, Canadian ham, anchovies, chopped garlic, pineapple, pepperoncini, extra cheese.
US$3.50
Premium topping for Lunch mini
Sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, Canadian ham, anchovies, chopped garlic, pineapple, pepperoncini, extra cheese.
US$1.75
Regular toppings for Small
Onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, green olives, diced tomato, jalapenos, Italian spice blend
US$2.25
Regular toppings for Large
Onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, green olives, diced tomato, Italian spice blend
US$2.75
Regular toppings Lunch mini
Onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, green olives, diced tomato, jalapenos, Italian spice blend
US$1.50
E.B.A. Large
(Everything but Anchovies). Actually, its onion, mushroom, green peppers, black olives, diced tomatoes, Sausage, Pepperoni, and Ground Beef. (Substitutions allowed for 2 toppings of equal value.)
US$27.95
E.B.A. Small
(Everything but Anchovies). Substitutions allowed for 2 toppings of equal value.
US$21.45
Garden Large
mushroom, onion, black olives, green peppers, and diced tomatoes
US$20.95
Garden Pizza Small
mushroom, onion, black olives, green peppers, and diced tomatoes
US$16.45
Hawaiin Large
Canadian style bacon and pineapple
US$19.10
Hawaiian Small Pizza
Canadian style bacon and pineapple
US$14.25
Sicilian Large
diced tomatoes, fresh garlic, Italian spice blend and a splash of extra-virgin olive oil
US$20.55
Sicilian Small
diced tomatoes, fresh garlic, Italian spice blend and a splash of extra-virgin olive oil
US$15.45
Gluten Free Crust upcharge
toppings will be charged at the price level for small pizza toppings
US$3.00

APPETIZERS

Our Famous Homemade Garlic Bread
served with 100% real Wisconsin butter. (pic shows 2 Garlic Bread)
US$3.99
Garlic Cheese Bread
our Famous Homemade Garlic Bread served with oven-melted Mozzarella cheese
US$4.95
Mozzarella Marinara
We cut the cheese from a block in-house and hand-bread them twice with seasoned bread crumbs from our Garlic Bread. Served with a side of Marinara sauce
US$10.95
Breaded Mushroom
US$10.95
Breaded Zucchini strips
US$10.49
Combo Platter
a variety of Mozz Marinara, breaded Mushroom, and Zucchini strips
US$13.50
Eggplant Strips
Hand-breaded eggplant strips. Served with a side of Marinara sauce.
US$10.95
Chicken Tenderloin Strips
BBQ or Ranch available on request
US$11.50
Jalapeno Cream-Cheese Poppers
served with side of Marinara or homemade Raspberry sauce
US$10.50
Minestrone Soup Cup
US$3.99
Minestrone Soup Bowl
US$5.99

Dessert

Tiramisu
US$6.95
Cannoli
US$3.50
Ultimate Chocolate Cake
US$6.95
Vanilla or Spumoni
US$3.50
Oreo Cheesecake
US$7.95
Limoncello Cheesecake
US$6.95

SPECIALS

Monday - Family Pizza Night
Large pizza with up to 3 toppings. 2 Garlic Bread & pitcher of soda or 1/2 carafe House wine for +$7. (Dine in only)
US$34.25
Monday - Lasagna special
Buy one lasagna, get one half price
$
Monday - Mini Pizza lunch special
a mini lunch pizza with 3 toppings and one Garlic Bread. Served from 11am to 3pm
US$13.50
Tuesday AYCE Pasta Special
Spaghetti or Penne / MeatSauce or Marinara with one Garlic Bread. All you can eat. (No leftover takeout, please)
US$13.99
Thursday Pizza special
Buy 1 pizza, get 2nd at half price
$
Friday - Baked Cod
Cod filets served with small side of pasta and Garlic Bread. Either regular style with Butter and Lemon or Sicilian style with Marinara sauce and Mozz cheese.
US$15.95
Friday - Fish Fry
Over half a pound of beer-battered cod that we prepare in kitchen. Served with waffle fries, coleslaw and one Garlic Bread
US$15.95

WINE

HOUSE WINE
$
BURGUNDY
US$5.00
CHARDONNAY
US$5.00
WHITE ZINFANDEL
US$5.00
WHITE
$
MOSCATO D'ASTI
Italy • Risata
US$7.00
MOSCATO
Italy • Castello Del Poggio
US$7.00
SAUVIGNON BLANC
Chile • Santa Rita
US$7.00
RIESLING
Germany • Fritz Zimmer
US$6.50
PINOT GRIGIO
Italy • Folonari
US$6.50
RED
$
RED MOSCATO
Italy • Risata
US$7.50
LAMBRUSCO
Italy • LoDuca
US$7.00
SANGRIA
Spain • Don Simon
US$7.00
PINOT NOIR
Italy • Folonari
US$7.50
MERLOT
Chile • Santa Rita
US$7.00
CABERNET SAUVIGNON
Chile • Santa Rita
US$7.50
MALBEC
Argentina • Santa Rita
US$7.50
CHIANTI SUPERIORE
Italy • Folonari
US$7.50
MONTEPULCIANO D'ABRUZZO
Italy • La Fiera
US$7.50

BEER

DOMESTIC
$
MILLER GENUINE DRAFT
US$5.00
MILLER LITE
US$5.00
MILLER HIGH LIFE
US$5.00
PABST BLUE RIBBON
US$5.00
BUDWEISER
US$5.00
BUD LIGHT
US$5.50
COORS LIGHT
US$5.00
BLUE MOON
US$5.50
CRAFT & IMPORT
$
MODELO
US$5.50
PERONI
US$5.50
CORONA
US$5.50
HACKER-PSCHORR WEISSE
US$6.50
CIDER BOYS
(variety)
US$5.50
SPOTTED COW
US$5.50
SET LIST
by Eagle Park Brewery - Muskego WI
US$5.50
GRAND MIMOSA CIDER BOYS
currently have Apple, Grand Mimosa and Peach Apple by CiderBoys
US$6.00
BRW-SKI AND OKT-SKI
US$6.00
ROOSTER BECK AMBER ALE
US$6.00
LAKEFRONT BREWERY
(Milwaukee WI)
$
LF IPA
US$5.50
LF EASTSIDE DARK
US$5.50
LF RIVERWEST STEIN
US$5.50

MISC

WHITE CLAW
Varieties
US$5.50
O'DOULS
Non-Alcoholic
US$4.50
ROADKING HD
Non-Alcoholic
US$5.00
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 414-475-0400